One reader asked about the pros and cons of a larger bluewater boat vs. a coastal production boat for long range cruising. Here’s our (subjective) view of the pros and cons of a larger boat, based on our experience with Fregata, an Amel 50, as compared to True North, a Beneteau 41.1 Oceanis.
Pros
- Comfort (space, equipment, privacy)
- Stability
- More flexibility (can sail in more conditions)
- Dryer and warmer in enclosed center cockpit
- Storage
- Guest capacity and comfort
- Speed under power
- Autonomy (fuel, water, power)
- Quieter (separate engine room)
- Ease (electric furlers, winches, davits, etc.)
- Safety on deck
Cons
- Speed under sail (does fine at 20 knots, but slower in lighter winds)
- Operating, maintenance, dockage and storage costs
- Complexity (more technology means more things to maintain / repair)
- Draft and mast height limit waters (i.e. no ICW, need deeper anchorages, etc.)
- Visibility (helm farther from action)